Carnivorous Plants Website
Carnivorous Plants in the Wilderness
by Makoto Honda



Carnivorous Plants
_______
III. Snap Trap
2017-03-15
Updated 2017-12-10

1. SNAP TRAP EVOLUTION

There are two snap-trap carnivores today: the Venus flytrap (Dionaea muscipula) and the waterwheel plant ( Aldrovanda vesiculosa). Overwhelming evidence from molecular phylogenetic reconstructions using different regions of DNA sequence (mat K, Chloroplast rbcL) indicates that Dionaea and Aldrovanda are sister to each other, strongly suggesting that these extant snap traps evolved from a common ancestor.

The molecular evidence further reveals that Aldrovanda and Dionaea form a clade that is sister to Drosera (sundews). This suggests that the common ancestor of Aldrovanda and Dionaea came from an ancient sundew-like plant.

Snap Trap Evolved Only Once
This most likely means that the snap-trap mechanism evolved only once in the common ancestor of Aldrovanda and Dionaea. Therefore, these snap traps are very similar --- the basic mechanism behind their snap-trap movement must have its origin in their common ancestor.

That is not to say that these two snap-trap mechanisms we see today in the Venus flytrap and the waterwheel plants are identical. Of course, there are some differences. After all, both lineages had 30-40 million years of completely independent evolutionary paths for crying out loud. Not to forget also that one is terrestrial, the other is aquatic, both traps well fine-tuned in their respective, entirely different environments. We can surely find differences between these snap traps.

What I am saying is that we do well seeking similarities --- rather than dissimilarities --- when we strive to unlock the mystery and wonder of these "most wonderful plants in the world."
 

2. HOW DID IT HAPPEN?

SNAP TRAP EVOLUTION -  A sudden, swift mutation must have occurred in one single individual in a population of ancient sundew-like plants. That individual produced many seeds (offspring) carrying this primitive, but workable, snap-trap trait to the next generation, and to the next, and to the next... The evolution of the snap trap has commenced.


3. WHICH EVOLVED FIRST?

An intriguing question remains as to which lineage evolved first --- Aldrovanda or Dionaea ---  from an ancient sundew-like plant? To put it another way, was the common snap-trap ancestor an Aldrovanda-like aquatic plant or Dionaea-like terrestrial plant? 

My take --- Aldrovanda...

When we talk about which came first, we are not suggesting that today's Venus flytrap gave birth to today's waterwheel plant, or vice versa. We are discussing the possible ways in which the ancestor of these extant plants diverged tens of millions of years ago...  

THE THEORY OF RECAPITULATION - "Ontogeny Recapitulates Phylogeny"

1)  Lloyd (p.182) - In Venus flytrap, the trap tilts to the right - mainly in younger plants, just like the clear bend seen in the mature Aldrovanda traps (see Lloyd/Darwin) --- Regarding this trap posture, Lloyd commented on the distinct advantage for Aldrovanda but no benefit for Dionaea. However, Lloyd did not extend this observation he made to an evolutionary context.

2)  Lloyd (p.181) comments on a young Venus flytrap (2 mm trap) ----> "The number of parenchyma cells ranges between two to four courses with large interspaces, in this feature again resembling the mature leaves of Aldrovanda much more than do the thicker mature leaves of Dionaea."
The structure of the mesophyll of the Venus flytrap leaves is more like that of aquatic plants....

3) Venus flytrap is very tolerant of flooding condition - possibly implying an Aldrovanda-like, aquatic ancestor.

4) Aldrovanda seems to share more common reproductive features with Drosera than does Dionaea.

Comparison of flower parts:  

Sepals / Petals
Drosera                 5 / 5 (4, or more than 5)
Aldrovanda          5 / 5 (4)
Dionaea                5 / 5

Stamens
Drosera                 5
Aldrovanda          5
Dionaea              15

Pistil
Drosera                 separate/undivided
Aldrovanda          separate/undivided
Dionaea                united

Style
Drosera                 separate/undivided
Aldrovanda          separate/undivided
Dionaea                united

Ovule
Drosera                  partial placentation    The ovary has five parietal placentas each bearing 8-13 ovules / pollen-to-ovule ratio 28.5...                          
Aldrovanda           partial placentation                                
Dionaea                 basal placentation      Superior ovary - single chamber

Pollen

Drosera                multiple operculate pores                         
Aldrovanda         3 pores with an operculum united in tetrads with 4 grains    (Cross, 2012)                           
Dionaea                    

Seed
Drosera               
Aldrovanda  
Dionaea                    

Ref:
Basal placentation: placenta is at the base (bottom) of the ovary. Simple or compound carpel.
Apical placentation: placenta is at the apex (top) of the ovary. Simple or compound carpel.
Parietal placentation: placentas are in the ovary wall within a non-sectioned ovary. Compound carpel.
Axile placentation: ovary is sectioned by radial spokes with placentas in separate 
locules. Compound carpel.
Free or central placentation: placentas are in a central column within a non-sectioned ovary. Compound carpel.
Marginal placentation: only one elongated placenta on one side of the ovary, as ovules are attached at the fusion line of the carpel's margins . This is conspicuous in legumes. Simple carpel.


4. DROSERA--ALDROVANDA--DIONAEA

Molecular evidence points to a common origin of the two snap traps (Aldrovanda & Dionaea), suggesting that the snap-trap mechanism evolved only once -- therefore, the basic mechanism for these snap traps must be similar... actually identical...

It is widely accepted that, in the case of Dionaea, the snapping of a trap leaf involves buckling. This is due to the initial convex curvature (doubly-curved) of the open trap lobes of a mature specimen. This "snap-through" buckling (or "flipping") does increase the speed of trap closure, a little. However, it has to be understood that the buckling, if it does happen, is not the main, driving force of the swift leaf closure, but rather, a result of it. The main cause of leaf closure is the pressure differential created between the opposite sides (upper & lower) of the trap lobes..... The same mechanism is responsible for the swift snap trap of Aldrovanda (no buckling here, though).

Molecular evidence further indicates that the common ancestor of these snap traps diverged from an ancient sundew-like plant --- perhaps the ancestor of the basal taxa, such as Drosera regia

This implies the basic mechanism responsible for the snap-trap operation has its root in the tentacle movement (and leaf folding) seen in the majority of extant sundew species (and in D. regia).

The basic mechanism for leaf motion common throughout Drosera-Aldrovanda-Dionaea evolution is most likely to be a sudden (or relatively quick) drop of turgor pressure on one side of the structure in question, creating an imbalance of pressure on the structure to cause it to bend.... In this process, the other side (epidermis) might be forced to stretch a little .... The recovery of the bending (or snapping for that matter) is achieved as a result of the side (epidermis) that lost turgor pressure restoring its lost pressure and then some to counter the stretch of the other side. This is accomplished by slow, normal, actual growth.


THE SHIFT OF PRESSURE DIFFERENTIAL DURING TENTACLE BENDING & SNAP-TRAP CLOSURE (2017-11-24)

Physical motions in plants are caused by different pressures between the opposite sides of the structure in question: one side expands, the other side shrinks, or both --- due to either turgor change or cell growth.

1)  In Drosera tentacle bending, the pressure differential between the opposite sides of the tentacle (stalk) occurs near the base first, and then gradually moves upward in the direction toward the tentacle tip.

2)  In Aldrovanda snapping also, the sudden pressure differential between the inner and outer epidermis in the motor region occurs near the midrib of the trap, and then gradually moves upward (within the motor region) during the tightening phase of the trap closure...

3)  In Dionaea snapping, the sudden pressure differential on the upper and lower epidermis of the lobes seems to occur in the upper half of the lobes --- that effectively causes the snap-through buckling of the trap lobes --- and then the pressure slowly moves downward toward the midrib during the narrowing phase of the closure...


 

1.  Drosera (sundews) ---- Illustrations

 Trap type: Adhesive - Stalked gland secretes mucilage, exhibits nastic/tropistic movement to secure prey.
 Sensory cells: epidermal cells at the tip of the tentacle (covered by two layers of glandular cells)
 Perception of stimuli: 2 action potentials within 1 minute to cause a tentacle bending...
 Mechanism: Sudden drop of turgor pressure on one side of the tentacle...
                       Tentacle bending (nastic / tropistic) - leaf folding

ILLUSTRATION ==========  DROSERA

2.  Aldrovanda (waterwheel plant) ---- Illustrations

 Trap type: Snap trap (aquatic).
 Sensory cells: trigger hair...
 Perception of stimuli: 1 action potential to snap...
 Mechanism: Sudden drop of turgor pressure on the inner epidermal cells in the motor region...
                       motor region  - narrowing (free-side lobe / bristle-side lobe)

ILLUSTRATION ==========  ALDROVANDA

In the illustration below, I chose to show the frontal views of the trap (all views except one lateral view) as if the leaf blade is extending toward you (not from the tip of the trap, as in the video). You can see that by noting the bristles shown on the left of the trap.

                      Aldrovanda vesiculosa  snap trap closure                         

Well, based on my repeated trials of measuring the screen image of this video, I concluded that, indeed, the A-B distance got shorter (in the left view of the video) after trap snapping, and therefore, the Aldrovanda closure is driven by warping of the motor zone of the lobes. This is in concert with the traditionally-held view by many past investigators, including  ...
 

3.  Dionaea (Venus flytrap) ---- Illustrations

 Trap type: Snap trap.
 Sensory cells: embedded in the indentation at the base of the trigger hair
 Perception of stimuli: 2 action potentials within 20 seconds to snap...
 Mechanism: Sudden expansion of mesophyll and loosening of the outer (abaxial) epidermal cell walls...

 ILLUSTRATION ==========  DIONAEA

 

 

Copyright (c) 2017 Makoto Honda. All Rights Reserved.

HOME